Showing posts with label Congress. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Congress. Show all posts

Saturday, August 3, 2019

DO YOU NEED UNEMPLOYMENT???


Employment is a situation which is born with the Industrial Revolution and brought up by Economic Liberalisation and Capitalism. So, Employment, Unemployment and Underemployment need a three-way explanation (a) Psychologically (b) Economically (c) Sociologically. 
Among all the explanations, Economic explanation is itself a self-explanatory to the raising issues of employment. The Economic definition of Employment is “Individual income derived from work and in turn, it affects the productivity of the Society or a Nation” So, Skills, Health, Education, Intelligence all are necessary components of an Individual’s Productivity component. 
Similarly, Psychological Explanation stress upon the willingness to work. Alber Lauterbach In his article published in American Journal says, “at any rate the “Wish to work” as a felt need that transcends the requirement of having a source of income is rather widespread and represents the striving for a social function and a feeling of being useful to others.” This explanation surely implies the need of strong Nationalism feeling. 


The Three Major sectors, where one can get employment are; (a) Agriculture (b) Industry (c) Service. 
Employment is divided into two major categories a. Self-employed and (b) employed by a firm, organisation, person etc. Again it is classified by the type of employment as (a) temporary worker (b) part-time worker (c) Permanent Worker. 
Under the Industrial Disputes Act, employees working in a managerial or administrative capacity, or those employed in a supervisory capacity earning more than Rs 10,000 per month, are excluded from the scope of this definition. 
Under the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act 1946 classify workmen according to the nature of the employment as (a) permanent, (b) Probationers, (c) Badli or casual, (d) Temporary 
The hue and cries on Present Unemployment are more political and less practical, Why?
First understand few things pointwise; (1) Shrinking Agriculture land thus increase of Temporary Labour force (2) Growing automation means minimize the use of Manual Labour Force, as most of the industries using contractual or probation labour force, so there is increase in unemployment (3) Lack of Skills/ Education also contribute the growth of unemployment of unskilled labour force (4) The participation of workforce of Muslim Population is much lower than the other religious population (5) the lowering participation of women folks also contributes overall downfall of work productivity of Hindustan. 


The CIME says the present unemployment rate for July 2019 is 7.6%. It also says the growing unemployment is due to the downfall of the automobile industry. The Downfall of Diesel/Petrol based automobile is a global phenomenon, even many countries discouraging the growth of carbon-emitting automobiles. According to the Data from the Ministry of Labour and Employment, the State-wise unemployment rate for persons aged 15yrs and above on usual status basis during 2012-13 to 2015-16, Hindustan’s unemployment rate is 4% (2012-13), 3.4 (2013-14) & 3.7 (2015-16). The International Labour Organisation says, actually there is more unemployment in 15 to 24 years age group but the unemployment percentage of above 25+ yrs age remained almost the same since 2012. 😆
Besides this, the increase of unemployment is an indirect consequence of General Election, as most of the government investment has been stalled due to Budgeting of Government Investments. 
Similarly, the NDA II passed the Minimum Wages Act to ensure minimum wages will sure change the employment/Unemployment scenario of Future India. 
👉My answer to the present unemployment scene is temporary and will wither out within one and two months.
You can read further analysis on unemployment at my blog ;🧐 👉




And👉 My HUMBLE REQUEST DEVELOPE THE FEELING OF NATIONALITY AND INCREASE YOUR SKILLS, POSITIVE APPROACH & PRODUCTIVITY and ESPECIALLY DON’T FALL PREY TO THESE SECULAR, LIBERAL, LEFT and CONGI BRIGADES' PROPAGANDA. 


Jai Hind
VandeMataram




Friday, October 20, 2017

FDI In India: Mouth filling but a Vaulting Horse

For the first time on August 17 this year, Astro-Physicists, Scientist for the first time detected the collision of two neutron stars, which happened at a distance of 130million light years from the earth. They also found that the collision also produced gravitational waves, light with an abundance of precious metal like Gold, platinum. The most astounding galactic activity divulged on 16th October, after much research and analysis. Where the precious metals went? Have we received the dust of those precious metals? If received, how much? These questions may seem to be much weird and irrelevant to our discussion
Let’s assume that the collision of those neutron stars is like allowing Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and its impact on a prevailing economy. Which has some immediate effect and some might be detected in the remote past. After the acceptance of Globalisation and subsequent Economic Liberalisation, Every developing country believed that FDI is like “a cosmic scale atom Smasher of energies for beyond humans ever will be capable to build”( what scientist described the Neutron stars collision) which can bring loads of fortunes to their economy. Yes, of course, since its implementation the FDIs proving as boosters to the economy of the developing and third world countries. All are much pleased with its short-term gains, but like the neutron stars collision many of the issues yet to be experienced. Some of them experienced but remain without explanation. 
Now, come precisely to our topic. I have studied many researched articles and papers on FDI, 80% of them equivocal on certain pros and cons. For the last two decades, since the implementation of FDI in India, the protests and criticisms on FDI remain almost limited to the Political debates. There are research works, but most of them lack inductive reasoning or authentic micro-level case studies on the FDI and its impact on the economy.
Indian Government in 1966 and 1985 tried to allow FDI but it failed.  In the late 1990s, during PV Narshima Rao(PMO)-Dr. Manmohan Singh(FM) severely debt-ridden India allowed FDI under the structural economic reform process. In 2006, under Dr Manmohan Singh(PMO) and P. Chidambaram(FM) further liberalised the FDI inflow through an automatic process, which doesn't need Government Permission but a compliance to Reserve Bank of India (RBI).  In 2013, India government made almost all the sectors open to the FDIs. In the Last two years, Under the Modi Government, it gets much enhancement with high voltage publicity on the name of “Make in India”. The Economic doldrums which arise after the Demonetisation and GST, Modi Government jumped quickly with a data sheet to prove that these reformations increased the FDI inflows. But In 2015, the India overtook China and US as the top destination for FDI.
The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) defines FDI as to take control of owning 10% or more of the business. Businesses that make foreign direct investment are often called as Multi-National Corporations (MNCs) or Multinational Enterprises (MNEs). An MNE may make a direct investment by creating a new foreign enterprise, which called Greenfield investment or by the acquisition of a foreign firm, either called an acquisition of or Brownfield investment.
Since its implementation, Indian Government insisting on the Technological Transformation/up-gradation, Employment Generation, easing Demand-Supply chain, Revenue Generation besides there is a belief that FDI can be a tremendous source of External Capital which can lead economic development.
Now come to the statistical figures, Research works like Sirari and Bohra (2011) on FDI & growth of service sector in India pointed out the growth of service sector to GDP is directly proportional to FDI. I’m here to point out some casual relationship between gloomy economic issues directly linked to FDI. For it, I’m taking three sectors Innovation, Agriculture, and Micro and small Industries especially cottage industries in India.
Mr. Mukharjee In his research paper quoting  Coughlin, Terza and Aromdee (1989, United States) said that the number of potential sites, state per capita income, manufacturing density within a state, better transportation infrastructure, higher unemployment rates and higher expenditures to attract FDI were positively linked to FDI flows. On the other hand, higher wages and higher tax rates had a negative impact on FDI flows.
However, In the Chinese context, based on panel data covering 98 hinterland cities of China for the years 1999 to 2005, Luo et al (2008) found that well-established factors such as natural resources and low labour costs were not important in determining FDI flows to China’s hinterland. Instead, policy incentives and industrial agglomerates were the most important determining factors for FDI flows.
There is no fixed rule which can attract FDI. It depends upon the variety of economic and Political situation of the invested countries. However, two things are noticeable from the above observations, firstly, the Investors have more decisive role than the government of the invested countries, and secondly, the major attraction for the FDI is low input cost both of Material and Human resources for production and Market. It can be explicitly concluded that the Invested country is always at the receiving end.
When we come to our own country, the FDI inflows to it dominated by the Automatic Route and followed by the Reinvested Earnings and acquisition of shares. FDI through Government approval route is gradually declining year on year basis (RBI, Atri Mukherjee).
Fig-1
In the initial years, the FDI was dominated by the retail sector, but later it is shifted to the Service sector. In 2014-15 the FDI inflows to service sector were INR27,369 Cr, in 2015-16 it increased to INR 45,415 Cr and during 2016-17 (March 31) it is INR58, 214 Cr. Between 2000 and 2017 total FDI inflows is INR316,568 Cr, which is highest among any other investment. This is followed by Computer Software & Hardware, Construction Development and Built-up Infrastructure, telecommunication, Automobile Industry and Drugs & Pharmaceuticals. 
But the India’s International Trade (Export and Import) largely dominated by Mineral fuels, Mineral oils (35% of the total imported Goods and 20% of Exported goods) followed by pearls, precious and semi-precious stones (11% & 12% ) and the top destination for export is USA and UAE, which is around 27% of the total exports. While the top two Importers to India are China and UAE, both contributed 22% of the total imports. It shows that in India, the sectors which attract highest FDI are not helping much in the international trade rather targeting domestic market. Now I place an example how the government is totally zilch on the Innovation and technological up-gradation of Indigenous products. The Lather and Lather products accounted almost 21% of the total exports but the FDI inflow to it is negligible i.e. .02%.
As said by the FDI fact sheet (till 2017, March 31), Government of India, since 2000 the Maharashtra (with some varies) was the topmost destination of FDI inflows with 31% of total inflows to India, followed by Punjab/Haryana (New Delhi 20%) , Tamil Nadu(7%), Karnataka(7%), Gujarat(5%) and Andhra Pradesh(4%). It is conspicuous that the economically advanced states receive Lion’s Share of FDI inflows.
Nunnenkamp and Stracke (2007) found a significant positive correlation of FDI with per capita income, population density, per capita bank deposits, telephone density, level of education and per capita net value added in manufacturing in India.
Fig-2
When we are talking about the employment and income growth, the Per capita FDI inflows has no direct link or an overlapping link to the per capita NSDP or Annual wages per worker. Andaman & Nicobar Island has 0% per capita FDI inflow during 2010-11 but the Per capita NSDP 76,883INR and annual wages per worker is 65,831INR, but during the same period Andhra Pradesh received 679INR per capita FDI inflow but the per capita NSDP is much below than A&N i.e. 62, 912INR and annual wages per worker is 61,007INR. Similarly, Goa Received highest per capita FDI inflows and its per capita NSDP is 1, 68,572 INR and annual wages per worker is 1, 26,788 INR. Although Jharkhand got 0% per capita FDI inflow and its annual wages per worker is much higher than that of Goa i.e. 1, 49,847 INR.
Fig-3
Now come to the Agriculture and Allied sector. The FDI inflows to it are below .58%. The total foreign investment is on fertilizers are .17%, Agriculture machinery (.11%), Food processing industries 2.27% (but most of the food processing industries dominated by meat and seafood). There are a thousand varieties of indigenous seeds and farm animals breeds but very few got patented. Now the foreign investment on Genetic Modified seeds is being encouraged by the Government. Some research works on Madhya Pradesh accused the forceful implementation of GM farming to the growing Farmers' suicide incident (Fig-2). At some point, the most developed States, which also attracts a major portion of FDI is unavoidably linked with Farmer deaths. (Fig-3)
Fig-4
The incoherent government policy on the Agriculture already weakened the Farmer's economy. Now to make FDI more attractive to Foreign Investor's government putting unreasonable pressure on the land to create a conducive environment. 
The investment procedures and double taxation avoidance treaties are the major cause of tax heavens. But the government has paid little interest to eradicate the menace. Even Last year, at several occasions Modi Government reiterated to bring reformations in the Mauritius Route (Fig-4) in FDI but no authentic steps have been taken so far. Rather the FDI has found a new route i.e. Singapore to avoid taxation in India. In the next article, we will discuss on the dark side of this international investment routes. 

Friday, October 13, 2017

Indian Perestroika: From this point to future

After 70 years, India going through a new phase. Government under Narendra Modi has tried to bring a structural change of the entire economic, social and governmental setup mostly influenced by the right-wing ideologies. Since 2014, India has also experienced many reformations some of which are government induced and some independently through legal and international aspects. Can all these reformations bring a better future? There is no simple answer to it, but a section is Hopeful and another section is skeptical to it.
After 3 years, we are in the middle of the evolution of Economical, Social, legal and political policies. However, the situation is such that we neither rewind the process nor has same enthusiasm to embrace all of them. Now be specific to the question, can this Perestroika of Indian Economy move forward with the same spirit? International Monetary Fund (IMF) in its recent world economic outlook and the World Bank both are positive but with an asterisk mark, which clearly stated: “if government thrust for the change remains unchanged”. Will the Government resolution remain same? It is a big question and also a game changer. Many International and national financial and governmental policy watchers including IMF and WB positive towards Modi Government for a single most powerful reason that it has a strength of democratic numbers, unlike previous government. In the contrary the forecast based on the mechanical analysis of statistical data only which has complete blind towards several relative issues like, the commitment of government machinery, implementation strategy,  and people’s emotional response to the pros and cons of the policies.
Policies are the binding force between centre and state, more precisely it determined the quality of the relationship between Government and its people, which in turn establish a collective effort for the nation’s development. Besides this, most of the economic policies are designed to solve particular problems at a particular time. Not all policies are a panacea to the plethora of problems for all the times. So, for the sustainability of the economic development, we have only two options, allow the policies for continuous evolution or formulate it with a collective approach. But, the fundamental predicament of the policies which brought disasters and severe criticism is Modi government’s plan to build watertight and congruent policy order with an aim for universal application throughout time (!) in a simple sentence, Modi Government unlikely to accept India as a unity of diversified interests and economic life.  
Of Late, the intellect of the Modi Government accepted the truth. On 11th of this month, in the 1st meeting of Economic Advisory Council (EAC) to Prime Minister emphasised the government to stay firm on the reformation but recommended to evaluate the policies and ready to take suggestions from beyond the rightwing contours. However, when the government has a congenital right-wing instinct and within a few months going to face series of assembly elections and general election, will this suggestion be implemented with its true spirit? The voters of 2019 will not be like 2014’s, the Image of the BJP is diminishing, Voters trust much strained due to promiscuous promises. In such condition, these democratic exercises have largely determined the future of the policies and the ability of the government.
Even if we presumed that the Modi Government will pass through unscathed in the next 2 years, the IMF figures are not so high-flying for India in comparison to the other nations with a similar economic scenario.
India's forecast in IMF's World Economic Outlook, 2017

In 2009, the year when the whole world was under the grip of severe economic recession, India’s total investment was 36.480 percentage of the GDP. In the current year, it further declined to 29.936 and as per the IMF forecast in 2022 it will be 30.936. It will be wrong to give a reason that with an increase of the government investment in infrastructure and productivity of the human resources the forecast will be altered. Without proper utilisation of the human resources and private investment, the government spending will be more than the revenue and subsequent decrease in savings.
This situation further pointed out by IMF, in 2009, the Gross National Savings (GNS) was 33.665 percentage of GDP. In 2017, it is 28.558 and in 2022 it will be 27.939 (% GDP). This implies government is spending is more its income than it produces.
The government revenue in the current year is 21.130 percentage of GDP while it was 18.518 in 2009. In 2022 it will be 21.326. Mean, the subsequent years the revenue generation is not increasing but will remain static. In contrary to the static revenue generation, the government expenditure is decreasing around 10% year-on-year basis. In 2009, the expenditure was 28,052, in 2017 it is 27,488 and in 2022 it will be 26,683. But recently, more WB supported SANKALP and STRIVE scheme and increase of salaries by implementing 7th pay commission recommendations, the government showed its keenness for the more government spending to counter GDP growth. This is also somehow against to the suggestions of the IMF and detrimental to the future sustainable and inclusive growth of India.
Further, the declining government savings implies two issues, one, in future manufacturing industry will be more dependent on the government purchases and second, and people will spend more on consumption. If we take the 2nd issue, it implies the growing CPI inflation in coming years.
Although IMF is hopeful for the Increase of GDP, it will reach 300,223,330 Billion INR (at current price) than the current 167,184,181 billion INR. Meanwhile, the data also indicates that the GDP deflator index also increasing. In 2009, it was 87.183 and current year it is 128.518 and in 2022 it is forecasted to 158.002. This implies two major things, the loopholes of the government planning to subdue the declining GDP and increasing the cost of living. Increasing cost of living is a clear sign of an increase of Poor-Rich gap and expansion of population under chronic poverty.
While, Modi government tries to blend its Right-wing economic model to the neoliberalism, but to tackle the economic problem it follows the Keynes model. If the government went further without any amendment to the present economic model, in near future government will be more blamed. If in order to gain mass popularity, the government would reduce or avoid taxation (Land, Gold, Oil not under the GST purview) and then meet the revenue shortfall by the creation of more artificial money, eventually it will lead more corruption like previous government coupled with a maladroit economic situation.

Monday, October 9, 2017

Modi Government in Reality-Shock


How much Modi Government trying to stifle the growing piques on the Jay shah's alleged financial gain issue, it is another incident which further exposed the Modi Government to the Reality-Shock Syndrome. Recently, the RBI’s Quarterly Policy Report and Earlier to this the Centre’s financial report on GDP and Economic Survey already made the Government incarcerated to the situation.
Prime Minister Narendra DB Modi and BJP National President Amit Shah (File Photo)
Jay AmitBhai Shah, the only son of most powerful Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) national president Amit Shah. The Wire, an online media house uncovered the alleged financial misappropriation which gives Jay a whopping 16,000 times monetary gain within 2 years. The amount of truth behind the accusation is yet to be proved (if Modi Government or a judicial proceeding wants). It has put an incorrigible question mark on the submission of the Modi Government and its precision on corruption. Although the issue is not related to any members of the treasury bench for which the government to take the blame, yet it is the subject directly impinge on the party’s very sensitive part, its image.
Before going to the details, it is relevant to quote Tom peters and Nancy Austin from their book “A passion for excellence: The leadership difference”. 
  • People have ego and developmental needs ...and they will commit themselves only to the extent that they can see ways of satisfying these needs.
  • People cannot be truly motivated by anyone else...That door is locked from inside.
  • When people are in an atmosphere of Trust, they will put themselves at risk, only through risk is there growth....reward...self-confidence...leadership.
Now, come straight to the 3rd point, since 2014 Election Campaign Narendra DB Modi time again has reiterated that the “corruption” is the biggest enemy of the country and it is the only hurdle to India’s development. He promised that his mission as Prime Minister is not to enjoy power but to uproot it. He also cautioned that the fight against corruption is not so easy and called the people’s support to be ready to bear the difficulties patiently during these fighting.  People unquestionably believed his Magniloquence. Extended support not only during demonetisation but also in his every disastrous reformation.
Contrary to the situation, during the same time, in recession stuck Brazil People came out to the streets and forced the government to rollback demonetisation. In Brazil, there was widespread resentment, spontaneous Protest sparked overnight. In many Western Countries, it is evident that if the government failed in any economic administration, the people’s remonstration is intense. But, in India the situation is different. People are more forbearing and indulgent towards such situations.
Now, come to the 2nd point, It seems that soon after 4 months of the implementation of demonetisation people de-motivated slowly but surely. As most of the economic reforms could not substantiate the Modi Government’s claim on corruption, Black-Money, Terrorism, Parallel economy, digital transaction, except the government forced surroundings. Rather the economic reforms posed as a stumbling block to the big ticket schemes like “Startup India”, “Make in India”, “Smart City Mission”, and “Skill Development”. Besides this, Modi-Government unable to boost the Export of indigenous products except for software
The Spice of India, most demanding products faced severe hardship during all these years. In the year, 2016-17 (Apr-June) the export reduced to 621.78US$ from 2432.85US $ (2014-15). Agriculture and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority (APEDA) Export performance abridged. In the year 2015-16, total export of Agri and Allied products was 43,369.62INR Cr which is reduced to 6,398INR Cr in 2016-17. PEC, a Government company, primarily engaged in export of projects, engineering equipment and manufactured goods, defense equipment & stores and import of industrial raw materials, bullion and agro commodities also faced financial constraints. Sales turnover reduced from 9780INR Cr (2013-14) to 3746 INR Cr (2016-17). Similarly, the sectors which declined are Processed meat (-77%), Leather and leather manufactures (-6.08%), Chemical and Related Products (-73%). Plastic & Rubber Articles (-2.68%), Base metals (like Iron, Aluminium, Copper) (-6.25%), except machine and Telecom instruments the export of other electronic items reduced. In the IT sector, Software service export growth dropped off (5.6% in 2012-13 to -.7% in 2016-17), IT-BPM export growth reduced from 11.1% (2012) to 7.8% (2017).  All these sectors accounted 40% of the total exported goods and services.
Last but foremost, In the above mentioned psychological traits of people in relation to an organization or a nation, the first assertion is on the people’s ego and development needs, which now are dwindling. As now, when people see that the Modi Government is noiseless on the perpetrators of corruption, Black Money rather their own men has been accused of the series of corruption charges. Employment is not generated as per the Election Manifesto but to a certain extent adding numbers to the unemployment.
It seems that the chest thumping on development and projecting himself “Vikash Purush” (Messiah of development) won’t produce development. The statistical figures of the government itself negate the claim of the Modi Government.  It shows that either Government is suffering from Hemispatial neglect Syndrome (a person who could not see or recognise the other half of the things) or it is a deliberated attempt of manipulation of facts, doctored data and managed publicity to hide its weakness.
For example, the Modi government’s one of the most hyped programs is the rural electrification scheme. The government maintained that even after 70years of Independence many villages having without electricity and they are doing a tremendous job to make all of them electrified. But in reality, before 2014, except Jharkhanda, Bihar, Odisha, UP, WB and Assam all the states achieved electrification between 90-98%.
In the Human development index (HDI) India already gained 4 positions before 4 and within last 3 years the condition not improved well even after the increase of budgetary allocation on social welfare schemes. According to the economic survey report (2016-17) part-2, Indonesia, Brazil, Sri Lanka and Malaysia are far better-performed nations than India. 
T S Venketaraman (Management Crises and Strategies for Growth, The Hindu Speaks on Management) rightly quotes, "... the financial difficulty is a result of several managerial mistakes made months or sometimes years ago. If a manager has misused funds once, he will do the same next time if he is given more money." 

Friday, October 6, 2017

How much optimistic is Modinomics?


On 5th October, almost one year after the implementation of Demonetisation, addressing the company secretaries Narendra DB Modi, The Prime Minister of India said, some get a sound sleep at night only after proliferate Pessimistic notion about the Government and on the Economy. According to the Human behavioral psychology, it is a sign of self-soothing expression, but his remark to the critics really mean?
Before digging into the Prime Minister Narendra DB Modi’s Economic policy and how optimistically it is taking the Country’s Economy growth forward, it is amusingly relevant to point out the possible inspiration which shaped his understanding.
Rashtriya Swayamsevak Samgha (RSS) which is the topmost advisory council to the present day BJP government on Statecraft and External affairs mostly influenced by Kautilya @Chanakya. There is no wrong to get inspiration from the great man, who laid the foundation stone of the Democratic Monarchical system and developed a pan Indian Spirit. But it is something abnormal with the brain that thinks which were relevant some 1500yrs ago can be implemented nowadays with exact significance.
Mr. Modi’s sudden announcement of Demonetisation, surprising announcement of various schemes, his Religio-Political gimmicks all are understandable from a chapter of Artha Shastra; the sloka (5.2.39-45) narrates how to exploit the gullibility of the people.(Kautilya- The Artha Shastra, L N Rangarajan, penguin)These include:
-Building overnight, as if it happened by a miracle, a temple or a sanctuary and promote the holding of fairs and festivals in honour of the miraculous deity;
- Exploiting an unnatural happening, such as an unseasonal flower or fruit, by making it into a divine phenomenon;
- Using secret agents to frighten people into making offerings to drive away an evil spirit;
- Playing tricks on people by showing a cobra apparently with many heads, or a stone cobra coming alive;
- selling remedies against evil occult manifestations.
If people are not taken in so easily, they should be frightened into doing so.
The next chapter also elaborates (5.2. 46-51) other methods of cheating to collect revenue. 
The Artha Shastra is not purely like modern day Economics. It is a treatise on statecraft and affairs of government and governed. Narendra Modi led government at the centre lacks this basic understanding about the economics. Why and How?

Firstly, the entire economic edifice and the administrative setup both good and bad are inherited from the previous government. But the Modi government has been evasive on this theory. Except for one or two instances, for some unavoidable circumstances, Modi government accepted the truth.
Secondly, which is, of course, the most perilous part that they always apprehensive to prove their stand right.
There may be a strong reason behind such approach; Firstly, BJP came to power by tarnishing every activity, schemes of the Congress-led UPA government, even though most of them were quite good and noble.  So it will backfire if they recognise it publicly. Secondly, if they recognise the legacy of the previous government, there leaves little room for them to prove they are doing the best.
This is the fundamental mistake of the Modi government which makes them further secretive in making economic and administrative affairs.
Since my focus is on the economic situation, with an apology I am taking out the administrative and Political issues and reserve it for another article.
Economics is Primary cogwheel of a person’s life. Throughout one’s life, economics will play a major role in determining what one do and how happy he is doing it. Not only individual’s life Economics equally vital for a country. It influences the affairs of the government and determines the wellbeing of the nation as a whole.
The “Laissez-faire” philosophy which since the beginning of the 19th century has been the driving force to determine the course of democracy and the role of the government is now becoming more complex. The advancement of new technologies basically Digitisation there is a growing demand for the de-materialization, de-monetisation, and democratisation of information, currency, and resources. The contours of Economics are also expanding and overlapping other areas. As the Income is largely depending on how effectively the nation or the individual participating in the economic process. Every step towards a more intricate economy brings new problems and economic interrelationships.
However, it seems that Modi government has learned the importance of the above facts. Hence with more enthusiasm, it is trying to implement the digital transactions. It demonetised, Simplified the Tax regime, wants to store the electronic database of every individual’s. But the Truth is, all these noble economic steps inherited from the previous government. Since Modi Government inherited the idea only not the understanding, it is facing a setback in every implementation.
In my previous article, “countering the economic crisis, Modi govt is on the horns of dilemma” I have analysed how India had made the standstill economy vibrant and successfully countered the 2008- 2010 global financial crisis and put the country’s GDP all-time high at +9%. Modi Government inherited a hale and hearty economy with some revolutionary schemes to implement further. The concept of the healthy economic scenario is neither a big leap nor total shifting of the track, but a sustainable and equitable development.
Between 2004 and 2012 most states did well in poverty alleviation. The Reduction of the poverty was 10 to 15 percent. Although the poverty in some states like Nagaland, Mizoram, Arunachal Pradesh, Gujarat increased but the well known poor states like Bihar, MP, UP, Odisha, Rajasthan improved their “poverty reduction rank.” Other government data indicates that the increase in the urban poverty and large-scale migration to urban areas.
An economic life of a rural person is quite different from an urbanite. Even though they earn less than their urban counterparts they are somehow protected from the immediate impact of the unstable economic situation. Since, they highly relied on the simple life, dependence on home/local produced foods/goods, their monotonous diet, etc. Most of the Village folks live out his years never going more than 25miles (a rough estimation) from his home village.

Most of the Demonetisation sufferers are the urban poor and lower income groups, who left the village and earned their livelihood from the unorganised sector. There is no authentic data to show how much the unorganised sector affected by the demonetisation disaster. What the figures government are disseminating, likely to hoodwink the faults.
Many ministers including Finance minister, High rank officers narrated it was to give bolt to “Parallel Economy” run by “Black Money.” But there is no applied term in economics to describe Black Money; it is unaccounted money or untaxed money laundered in Tax heavens. The Parallel economy in its general usage refers to Black market. But in economics it has no negative sense, but a definition to bring more effective monitoring techniques. Economists like Feige defined it as, “hidden economy as including those economic activities which go unreported or are unmeasured by the prevailing techniques for monitoring economic activities.”
However, it is sure that the role of Hard currency for most of the activities in Black Market is highly implausible. On the other side there is an innocent world, where a Parallel economy has prevailed since time immemorial. It is the rural area which suffered most (though the impact varies from state to state depending upon the economic activities). How scanty the earning, it is hard earned from the unorganised sector. It never deposited in Banks, maneuvered by the unregistered local money lenders.
My firsthand experience says the demonetisation triggered the reverse migration. Many returned to the village. Ironically, before demonetisation, Modi Government contracted the budget allocation for many social welfare schemes. Due to contraction of the revenue allocation State governments were reluctant to spend on Infrastructure. The mining sector was under regression. The Market was highly susceptible because of the possible implementation of new tax order. Agriculture was under stress. Those who returned to villages found no employment immediately. For them, two optioned opened either they borrow money or sell and mortgage what they have. Modi Government totally closed its eye to all these factors.
Good Economy produces two things one is “Constant” another is “Equilibrium”. In Constant, like a cogwheel, it pulsates other things to run. Secondly, when a new economic composition brought forth it must give rise to a state of equilibrium. If the new economic order brings any capricious result it never termed as good economy.
In contrary, Modi Government arguably unwavering by debating that it is quite common to protest any novel Idea. However, this is rhetoric filled with a fallacy of Logic and reason.
Without rectification, the economic order, either in deliberation to implement its political agenda or to satiate its inferiority complex Modi Government has unabated in committing series of economic mistakes. It is a general sense of understanding that when the economic condition is highly volatile, one should not go for external aggression or become a perpetrator to the warlike situation. But Modi Government increased Defense budget, Undergone two warlike situations – Pathankot and Doklam Standoff, did surgical strikes. Conversely, in a fully employed economy, we must choose between guns and butter, If we use a big chunk of our productive resource for national defense our standard of living in civilian good is going to be correspondingly lower.
It is quite amazing that in one hand Modi government is talking to take India to a new height and showing dreams to make it Master of the World (Viswa Guru), on the other hand, it is tightening the noose around a healthy economy.
Before concluding my analysis, it is relevant to point out a major issue which may bring disaster to the Indian economy in the near future. As a close watcher of the world especially Indian Economy, I felt that the consumer behaviour of the Indians highly manipulated not by the market but by the Ruling Party (!). The demand for the variant goods now squeezed (may be due to various economic reasons) but there is a selective dissemination of demands, orientation for what to choose and what not to be chosen, imposed preference for a particular variety of goods. When we are competing with the world especially a neighboring country (China) which is very strong in the retail chain, such practice may bring the catastrophic result to many MSME sector and Innovations. It is imperative from the fact world market is skeptical to the “Make in India” products; Even The country’s own defense sector is not willing to absorb it.
Last though not the least, Now Modi Government planning for another blunder. It proposed to hold simultaneous elections. The argument for it is to reduce the burden of expenditure. But Modi Government should not forget that the Economy is a perennial process. The reformation only can be fruitful when you work persistently by remaining on the track. The early election may in distance future give some relaxation to the economy but the state exchequer which is already under the stress could be more brittle with this step.

By general agreement, it is the job of government to establish and enforce the basic rules to enable men to deal effectively together. Without understanding this, the slogan “collective effort, inclusive growth” will be an epithet of the abysmal dismay of Indian Economy. 

Sunday, March 12, 2017

Critical analysis of Narendra Modi’s UP Win: Survival of the Fittest

After the spectacular Winning Streak of Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in the Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand Our Prime Minister Narendra Modi Twitted by congratulating the voters and incessant workers. Reacting to the twit I have written “Fate prevails everywhere, neither Force of work nor the high education, but congrats for your win.”
My observation must draw severe criticism and might be doing injustice to the noble workers who worked for the Narendra Modi without any want of favour, but I’m right in my view in one point, as it is purely to understand the conducive environment on which Narendra Modi or BJP has least role.

 
BJP won 312 seats excluding its ally like Apana Dal out of 403 assembly seats. Similarly in Uttarkhand it won with thumping majority of 57 seats out of 70 seats. This winning is unprecedented and even unexpected (!) for BJP itself.  All the exit poll predictions went wrong, All psephologist miscalculated the caste and religion oriented vote base. Although, it is not a big deal for BJP to win in Uttar Pradesh as it has satisfactory presence since last 40 years since the party’s inception. It also seized power three times (for 6 years) Kalyan Singh became CM two times (June 1991- Dec 1992 & September 1997 to November 1999) and Rajnath Singh for one time (October 2000 to March 2002). In the 2014 General Election BJP won 71 MP seats out of 80. But the Point of Discussion is, the Collapse of caste and religion based electoral and Whopping majority to a religious agenda based party in Uttar Pradesh (Amazingly Even after opposition from Rajnath Singh, Sahanwaj Hussain etc Modi and Amit Saha did not give a single ticket to a Muslim Candidate).  How and Why BJP got such big mandate? We will analysis thoroughly the possible answers but before that it is relevant to throw some light on the Saffron surge in India.
Until now BJP has its chief minister in 11 states- Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Gujarat, Haryana, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand and with allies it enjoying power in another Four states- Andhra Pradesh, Jammu and Kashmir, Sikkim and Nagaland out of 29 states.
In 2014 general election BJP led NDA got absolute majority 282 seats excluding its allies (total 336). It got 171,660,230 popular votes which is 31.34% of the total votes polled. If we take the popular votes and percentage with 1999 general election which is another biggest achievement of the BJP, (as this is the first time in India where a non congress government lasts full five year term) in 1999 BJP led NDA won 254 seats out of BJP won 182 seats but the popular votes were 135,103,344 which is 37.06% of the total votes polled. If we compare between 1998 general election and 2014 in a nutshell, the impressive presence of the left parties and political inclination towards regional parties were clearly visible. It was the golden era of regional parties.



But now things has been changed, left parties lost their grip over Indian voters except Kerala and shrinking of vote base of regional parties. 2014 is a political transition period.
The period between 2009 and 2014 is the last phase of the electoral system, which has been continued since 1952. The voters are from new generations, less influenced by the independence struggle but more to create their own new identity. Since 2004, many Socio-psychological factors reshaped the Political Scenario. Growing literacy and lack of employment opportunities in both Government and Private sector people created their own opportunities. For this they wanted a less hassle free system which free from corruption and more space for economic independence which previous government failed to answer. The Demonetisation has given the best answer to it at least theoretically. More poor and middle class People perceived that this will rearrange the past economic system where they had been deprived from the opportunities. This is a blessing of disguise for Narendra Modi Government. Nationalism and abhorrence to alien inhabitants are other aspects of this ‘Economic Independency’.
Some Noted Journalists like Rajdeep Sardesai and Pallavi Ghosh pointed out the BJP’s Campaign through the Ujala Scheme much before the election. Some Pointed out the BJP’s Support to abolish Tripple Talaq and subsequently Muslim women support to it. Just Before the UP election RSS again tossed its anti reservation agenda, but it couldn’t hold the ground where 60% population are under this reservation benefit. BSP’s Supremo Mayawati wanted to take this issue forward but unlike Bihar election miraculously it died before gaining Political momentum.
Lets a close look of the caste wise division of voters in UP, 22% are from forward castes, 40% from OBC (including 18% Muslim) and 21.3% Dalits (SC/STs). Even after this, Most of the BJP candidates won with more than 15 thousand votes than their nearest candidate.
Besides this, there was image tarnishing issues against BJP as anti liberty, anti secular, hardcore Hindutwa agenda, Hooliganism in Educational institutes particularly in and around the Uttar Pradesh. But BJP saved from the onslaught putting forth the Nationalist agenda. Even Narendra Modi and his team until now except publicity have not done anything to solve the real nationalism issues.
The linking of terrorism to a particular religion is always the voice of BJP’s frontal organisation. The Lucknow Thakurganj encounter, Accquital of Swami Assemananda in Ajmer Dargha Blast case, Madhya Pradesh Train accident, etc might be created havoc for BJP, but it has little impact on the BJP’s Image.
The Political environment in the neighbouring states Except Bihar and Delhi all are under BJPs rule. This created a positive vibes among the voters. Bihar, where BJP lost assembly election might influence some on the northern parts but couldn’t happen.  RLD’s Lalu Yadav campaigned against BJP, but Nitish Kumar remained silent or more less supported the BJP through his endorsement for Demonetisation.
In the 2014 general election BJP got 42.3% vote share, while SP 22.2%, BSP 20% and Congress with 7.5 percent vote share. It was believed that there was no anti-incumbency against SP’s Akhilesh Yadav. But the family feud cost him dear more than garnish his image. SP Believed that for the winning in assembly election one has to get 31% vote, if it joined hand with Congress both will get almost same vote share. It is the point where most of us including I failed to understand. BJP’s Vote share remained intact.

The Gathbandhan strategy was not properly calculated and even overly estimated. In the 11th March Akhilesh Yadav around 10 am said he has no hesitation to go for alliance with BSP to defeat BJP. But this should be planned before. If we count the vote share this will be clearly understood. In 2017 assembly election BJP and its allies begged 34,403,039 popular votes which is 39.7% vote share. Similarly SP+Congress’s popular vote is 18,923,689 (21.8%) and BSP’s 19,281,352 (22.2%)
Infrastructural development like express Highway not able to allure voters who were reeling under the 20 years misrule of BSP and SP, no improvement in the internal infrastructure like roads, school, Hospitals etc.
Under current against SP and in favour of BJP is never be materialised without the active support of Government Officers especially in law order situation and election management. They supported BJP alike the active Karyakartas of BJP and RSS.

The alleged EVM fraud is only a small part which contributed for the BJP’s Victory the other things which helped is the skilful management of the situation. It was clearly visible soon after the 4 phase election all the major national media supported the BJP and campaigned for it. 

Monday, March 6, 2017

A Political equation in Uttar Pradesh never changed “Even for BJP”

"If we are taking into account of the past equations and Political Traditions, the 2017 assembly election will see similar Result. BJP already estimated it....through the desperation for Narendra Modi and his team clearly corroborating the evidence....in opposite side, the answer is clear for the questions like, Why BSP is not aggressive in Election campaign? Why Congress Withdrawn the "Priyanka Campaign" in the middle? Why SP- Congress is so casual in campaigns?"

Uttar Pradesh Assembly Election 2017, an comparison 


Who is going to win India’s most decisive Political Battle which is undergoing in Uttar Pradesh for 403 Assembly seats?  At present context, a tricky question to answer due to two things, primarily for the restrictions of Election Commission and secondly, the paid publicity and Campaigns surrounded the facts. Contrary to the Restrictions, personal opinions in Social Media and panel discussions flooded with calculations and predictions. It might not be so difficult to predict the result but it is more difficult to categorize who are wrong and right.  Why? I can represent the words of India’s first anti congress Prime Minister Moraji Desai on the political predictions “An expert gives an objective view...he gives his own view”. Since taking into account everyone is correct in their calculations and predictions I here giving some facts and figures which can throw some light on the political traditions and election equations of the winners and losers.
Congress lost its political image and influence on Uttar Pradesh during the emergency. Although it regained its position in the assembly and general election held soon after the death of Indira Gandhi yet could not last long. 1985 assembly election was the last election where Congress got an absolute majority with 269 seats especially due to the sympathy for the assassination of Indira Gandhi. In 1989 General and assembly election parliament seats reduced to 15 and assembly seats to 94. However Congress managed to save its political reflection through a meticulously planned alliance with ace regional forces.
Almost for the last 40 years, except 1977 and 1985 election the politics has been based on caste & religion.  Since the disintegration of the Janata Dal the fight is between Regional parties and BJP. In the Uttar Pradesh election BJP always played religious card whereas Regional parties like BSP, SP and RLD has their own agenda on caste. In 1991 BJP with a whopping majority (221 seats) won the election solely on Ram Mandir and Hindu revival Issue. But it could not last long. SP and BSP emerged as ace forces for the CM race. 1993 assembly election had seen a curious situation, where two opposition political parties united only to counter BJP’s Religious agenda. In the latter years, BJP tried to grab the power through alliance but soon realized that it is a sour relation and could not grant desirable result.
In 2002, SP won 143 assembly seats while BSP 98 and BJP 88 seats. Congress and RLD were satisfied with 25 and 14 each. In 2007 assembly election BSP won 206 seats, SP 97, BJP 51, Cong 22 and RLD 10.  In 2012 assembly election SP won 224 seats, BSP 80, BJP 47, Congress 28, RLD 9.
If we took into the account of the comparison between General elections and Assembly elections than it is clear that General election has less effect on Assembly Election and vice versa. For example in 2009 general election 2004 SP won 35 out of 80 seats, BSP 19, BJP 10 and Congress 9, but in 2007 election BSP emerged as a winner. Similarly, in 2009 SP got 23 out of 80, Cong 21, BSP 20 and BJP 10. Despite 21 seats congress managed to save 28 assembly seats.
If we taking into account of the past equations and Political Traditions, the 2017 assembly election will show a similar picture. BJP already estimated it and the desperation for Narendra Modi and his team clearly corroborating the evidence.
There are Five major things which can be summarized for “Why BJP’s ambition to regain UP cannot be fulfilled”
  • 1.        BJP could not able to polarize Hindu Vote unlike earlier elections
  • 2.       South UP where the Narendra Modi’s parliamentary constituency falls is surrounded by BSP and Congress vote banks. It is quite difficult to pull the voters from Congress Vote banks, the only option is BSP but BSP already polarized the votes against RSS and BJP’s anti-reservation policy.
  • 3.       BJP cornered Muslim in the distribution of seats but more reliant on his ‘divide and rule’ trick for the Muslim votes. But it could not break through its own plan.  
  • 4.       There is no Chief Ministerial Candidate and the entire election affairs have been handled by the Modi-Saha team, which gives limited access to the publicity to owe voters unlike “UP ke ladke”(UP’s own children slogan by SP-Congress alliance). Narendra Modi tried to save his plan by promoting “Adopted son” but failed utterly. Besides this, the entire election campaign based on the “Modi’s Charisma” which is not as before.
  • 5.       BJP speculated that it will get benefit from the Mulayam Family feud and anti-incumbency factors but in contrary family feud more or less cleaned the dark marks on the Akhilesh, like link to anti-social elements and anti-incumbency. Surprisingly, BSP also not targeting the SP rather speared against BJP.



Wednesday, February 22, 2017

Odisha Panchayat Poll 2017: BJP’s Vote raise is a gift not deliberate

On 22nd February, 2017, one day after Panchayat Election and a few hours before the beginning of Budget season Ruling Biju Janata Dal (BJD) supremo Naveen Patnaik patting his party MLAs at the Legislative Party Meeting advised not to dishearten and increase relation with the grass root voters. On the other hand, replying to the media, he said, he can give comment only after 25th February, only after the official declaration of the results (!). These words send an alarm to opposition parties and others who are happy with the decreasing seats of BJD. Could BJD revive after this blow? Anything can happen in Politics, but it is relative to the situations which is unforeseen.
In the last article “Odisha Panchayat Poll 2017: BJD bleeds, BJP sucks, congress stucks” in pointed out how both BJD and BJP getting benefit from the weakness of the state congress party. Now I again am reiterating my opinion with a relative truth. In future, If Congress could revive, both the parties will suffer.
Let’s have looked into these election figures, in 2007 Panchayat Election, BJP and BJP were in a coalition government but choose a friendly fight. Consequently, BJD had secured 345 seats, Congress 303 seats, and BJP 129 seats. BJD had a majority in 15 districts, Congress had formed 11 Zilla Parishads with an absolute majority, BJP retains only two (Baragarh and Deogarh).
In 2012 panchayat election, BJD turned away from BJP, with whom it shared power for almost 9 years and fought independently. BJD got thumping result, it had made fresh inroads into congress and BJP territories like Kalahandi, Sambalpur, Sundergarh, Dhenkanal and seven other districts. It had captured 27 Zilla Parishads. BJP could not able to form a single Zilla Parishad. Similarly, Congress which had Presidents in 11 Zilla Parishads in 2007 has got a majority in Jharsuguda, Koraput and Kandhamal districts.
In 2012, BJD got whooping 651 ZP seats, while Congress lost almost 177 seats to BJD. BJP reduced to 36. Even Independent candidates did well than BJP, in total, they got 38 seats.
(Odisha CM Naveen Patnaik with BJP Union minister Dharmendra Pradhan, During a Swatchha Bharat Event-File Photo

In a recent poll, BJP’s has performed well in Angul, Bolangir, Baragarh, Dhenkanal, Kalahandi, Kendrapara, Khordha, Malkangiri, Mayurbhanja, Sambalpur, Sonepur and Sundergarh. Most of the districts except khordha, Kendrapara, Malkangiri and Dhenkanal are in Western Odisha. Western Odisha always regarded as stronghold of BJP, even national party leaders gave more focus on it during the 2014 general and assembly election. Almost all MLAs are from western parts. Before the Panchayat Election BJD already smelled its defeat in these parts, as its gimmick on Mahanadi Water dispute failed drastically. But BJPs remarkable performance in Kendrapara, which is regarded as BJD’s castle, Malkangiri, which was once strong hold of Congress and Khordha where no other parties except BJD has its presence is noteworthy.
Even though Bijaya Mahapatra, the brain behind BJD and Naveen Patnaik’s ace opponent is now with BJP, yet Local Leaders alleged that BJD’s recent defeat in Kendrapara is due to BJD MP Baijayant Jay Panda. It is said that he himself recommended to BJP 4 names for Zilla Parishad and all were elected. BJD captured Malkangiri from Congress but recently it lost peoples support due State government’s apathetic attitude towards (Japani encephalitis) JE deaths. Khrodha is politically sensitive as it is capital district and since 2000 BJD never lost a single election here. The lost is due to growing goondaism of BJD MLAs like Prashant Jagadev, and unworthy performance of MP Prasanna Patshani, popularly called as Chicken Baba among political satirists. Defeat in Dhenkanal , many believed that due to the political indifference of the BJD MP Tathagat Satpathy.
Naveen Patnaik with Baijayant Jay Panda and Tathagat Satpathy- File Photo


Prasanna Patashani (MP, Khrodha), Baijayant Panda (MP, Kendrapara) and Tathagata Satpathy (MP, Dhenkanal) are many times ostracized for their antiparty stance. But people’s support to BJP during the Panchayat election is like a gift but not deliberate. 

Tuesday, February 21, 2017

Odisha Panchayat Poll 2017: BJD bleeds, BJP sucks, congress stucks


“We have no option, Congress cannot give us protection, so we supported BJP candidate,” this is a version of Jati Pradhan of Basuaghai Panchayat which is under the Bhubaneswar Ekamra assembly constituency. This is the assembly segment where Ashok Panda, state Tourism, and Culture Minister won three times consecutively. In 2012, all the candidates including Zilla Parishad were from ruling Biju Janata Dal(BJD). ZP member Sangram Paikaroy left BJD as he had an aspiration for the MLA ticket but denied in 2014 but denied. As there is no scope to get elected from a Congress ticket he joined BJP in 2016.
There are several such instances across the state where discontent BJD leaders either supported BJP or have got BJP ticket. In the fifth and final phase of Panchayat election ended on 21st February, 2017 Ruling BJD which stood top in the last four phases got 61 ZP seats, BJP won 55 seats, Congress 9 and others 3 ((the Figures are real-time unofficial results, not declared by Election Commission))
The dramatic change of voting pattern in Odisha is an undoubtedly a great blow to the ruling BJD, who ruled the state almost for 17 years. But the Congress who has been remained main opposition pushed to the third position. It is not a great surprise to see the decreasing support of the ruling BJD as it is already reeling under anti-incumbency factor and growing discontent among the party leaders and cadres. But BJP’s impressive rise in the present Panchayat Election from the political dark state is point of analysis.  Earlier, BJP was in coalition with BJD almost for 9 years. In 2009, just before state assembly and general election BJD estranged BJP citing its alleged involvement in the Kandhamal violence. Most of the party leaders went into absurdity; they have further degenerated for their alleged involvement in most of the scams, Party remained without or feeble grass root organization and ambiguous leadership. Just before Panchayat election Party also under sharp criticism over the dilly-dallying the decision on the construction of dams over the upper course of the Mahanadi River by Chhattisgarh government.
In 2014 assembly and general election BJP’s performance was good in comparison to 2009 assembly and general election. In 2009, not a single MP got elected from BJP, only 6 of its candidates own in assembly poll. But in 2014, not only it fetched only one Parliament seat, but also in 10 parliament segments it was neck and neck fight and lost 10 thousand votes. The MLA seats also increased to 10. During the 2014 election, it was clear that BJP and BJD were feeding on the Congress vote bank, yet lion’s share had gone to BJD.
Since 2014, Odisha has been under the special focus of the BJP. Almost all the central leaders and Ministers visited Odisha more than once. Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited Odisha more than 5 times. It has also given 2 lucrative and important ministerial berths, one is Tribal ministry and another is petroleum and natural gas. Just before the 2014 general and assembly election many a leader from the wobbling congress party joined BJD, while discontented BJD supporters and leaders joined BJP, many even got selected to important office bearer posts, got a ticket and even elected. After victory of BJP in the national politics and INC’s shameful defeat in 2014 the disintegration of Congress and BJD grew manifold.
File Photo- Naveen During BJD rally at Bhubaneswar

File Photo- Prime Minister Narendra Modi

Out of total 850 ZP seats BJD won 435, BJP 314, Congress 56, others 16. In 2012, BJD won 651, Congress Stood second Position with 128 seats, BJP with 36 seats and others including Independent won 22 seats. (the Figures are real-time unofficial results, not declared by Election Commission)  This shows that Loss of Congress is not so high than BJD yet voters now seeing BJP as alternate to BJD.
Many leaders like Union Minister Dharmendra Pradhan, Party’s national general joint secretary(Organisational), Party President Basant Panda, State Prabhari Arun Singh may take credit for this remarkable victory , but the reality  is different.
It is apparent that even after the feeble grass root base BJP’s impressive rise was due to Narendra Modi. Similarly, in 2000 election BJP’s performance in the state at large governed by the charisma of Atal Bihari Vajpee.

There is a saying rural Odisha, Nephew becomes more joyful when he sees straw pile of his uncle. The impressive winning of BJP in the present Panchayt election could not strengthen the Party in near future. It will again lose its ground if Congress got strength, but it seems to be unattainable in coming Municipal election scheduled on 2018.